This came with two products from the Skin [Mal:Gem] range which are the Smoother Exfoliation Toner and the Moist Deep Moisture Care Freshener.
This whole range is just toners. Mal:Gem comes from the Korean pronunciation of the Hangul symbols for cleanness, clarity and pureness. The six toners are Fresh, Smoother, Moist, Deep Moist, Essential and Emulsion. I got the Smoother and the Deep Moist.
It also came with some cotton pads, but they are just normal cotton pads and I don’t tend to use them in my skincare routine since I prefer my hands, so I haven’t reviewed them here, sorry!
The packaging of these is very clean and classy. A more mature look than Etude House normally go for and one of the main reasons I was intrigued by this kit. The full size bottles look like frosted glass, but are actually a thick plastic which is better for my clumsy hands and morning stumbles, but it looks fancy. The white background and colour accent for each different type is a cool touch as well. The Smoother toner has a subtle floral pink design on it and the Deep Moist has dark blue raindrops.
The Skin [Mal:Gem] Smoother Exfoliation Toner is a watery light, toner that is meant for dry, hyperpigmented and trouble prone skin. It claims to remove all dead skin cells, leaving soft and smooth skin underneath. The active ingredients for it are fruit acids in green grape.
First off, I do not have dry skin, but I found this worked quite well for me. The watery style of it helped I think. I used it for the equivalent of a month before the sample ran out and that was using it day and night so a little goes a long way.
When I started using this, I had a couple of hormonal breakouts I had been unsuccessfully trying to clear up. This managed it in about a week. The angry, red spots were clamed on the first day and visibly reduced on the second. My condition kept improving until, by the end of the week, the spots were barely visible at all. Two more days and even the slightest trace was gone.
I also liked the smell of this, quite citrus-y with floral hints. It smelled clean and that made me hopeful that my break out would be gone soon.
It absorbed very quickly on my skin and left no residue which I really like, however it did find it drying. I thought this odd since it is supposed to be for dry skin and mine has oily tendencies, but I found this drying. I would only use it on days where my skin felt especially oily or I had a break out and it would clear up both problems easily but I would have to moisturize more to compensate for the dryness.
I probably would get a full-size of this because the value is really good and it would be handy to have around when I need help with break outs. I wouldn’t be able to use it as my absolute go-to because of the dryness thing though.
The Skin [Mal:Gem] Deep Moist Moisture Care Freshener, however, was a very moisturizing product. It is filled with nutrients to provide the skin with vitamins and is aimed at dry and sensitive skin.
The smell was similar to the Smoother one, but I found a more rosy floral current than a jasmine-y one.
I used this toner first when trying them out, but this is partly what caused my break-outs which the Smoother had to come in to fix up. It was way too moisturizing for me. My oily skin really did not appreciate it.
The consistency is much thicker than the Smoother option and the feel of my skin was sticky and heavy. I really didn’t enjoy it at all.
I tried a few different methods in using this to see if anything would work for me. They were as follows:
1) I used it normally as a toner, but this broke me out pretty badly and then a hormonal break out worsened it. This was when I brought it the Smoother toner instead.
2) After my skin had calmed down, I used it in the emulsion stage instead, but with a cream over the top of it, it still broke me out. Again, I called in the Smoother.
3) I used it as a Night Cream. After my previous experiences, I knew I wouldn’t be able to use it during the day. As a night cream it worked pretty well and I didn’t break out. However, I have so many other nicer creams that I didn’t really use it much after discovering this. I used up the last of it as a crutch in between running out of one cream, but not wanting to start another while waiting for this new one to be shipped to me. And also, I like using them up. I want to get my money’s worth. Even as a night cream though, it was sticky and heavy and I didn’t really like using it. It also only needed a small amount so it took ages for me to use up.
I think this would be good for people with dry skin. It didn’t liken to my skin very much at all, but I can imagine it would be a different story on another skin type.
Conclusion
Etude House Skin [Mal:Gem] Smoother Exfoliation Toner
Smell: 2/3 – Pretty good
Face Feel: 1/3 – Drying
Effectiveness: 2/3 – Cleared my break-outs
Packaging: 2/3 – Clean and classy
Price vs. Worth: 2/3 – Good price for the amount you get.
Total: 9/15 – A good product to have if I have any break-outs, but if I find something that clears them up without drying me out, I will start using that instead.
Where to get it…
RoseRoseShop: 9,600won
TesterKorea: 9,600won
W2Beauty: 20, 095won
Etude House Skin [Mal:Gem] Moist Deep Moisture Care Freshener
Smell: 2/3 – OK, not great though
Face Feel: 0/3 – Sticky and heavy
Effectiveness: 1/3 – Made me break-out twice.
Packaging: 2/3 – Really nice
Price vs. Worth: 2/3 – For the right skin type, this is really good value.
Total: 7/15 – This product is clearly not aimed at my skin type and I think it would be really good for people with dry skin. It is deeply moisturizing and I think it would help that a lot.
Where to get it…
RoseRoseShop: 9,600won
TesterKorea: 9,600won
W2Beauty: 20,095won
My overall view of this for myself was a hit and a miss. I really liked like the packaging and I think it is excellent value for the full-size versions. It’s just a shame it made me break out, but that’s OK, I still enjoyed trying it out. As a kit though, I don’t really think these two products go together. One that is drying and another that is too moisturizing. They should do two different kits instead since there are definitely more fitting products in the line that suit each much better. They should rename this the Polar Opposites Skin Care Kit or The Everyday Kit for Combination Skin That is Bipolar In Its Combination-ness, or do you think that’s too wordy?
Next time I will be reviewing my last Etude House kit from the first haul I got. It is the Etude House Like 20 Skin Care Kit.
So until then, Tschüss!
X
– L